I bought this tray from Home Sense:
When I bought it, I knew full well I wouldn't be keeping it as is. Unfortunately, and surprisingly, hubs liked it with the rooster and didn't want me to change it. Too bad.
So I spent a unhealthy amount of time comparing and debating about which paper I wanted to use to cover it. My brother and his crafty gf gave me a economy sized package of nice papers for Christmas, so I had a lot to choose from. Finally settled on an orangey-beige-y with a bit of blue design that easily matched up because the tray is longer than 12".
A little hodge-podge, a few unwanted air bubbles and we've got a brand new, much nicer tray:
I even used it last night for our first significant dinner party (7 people total) to cart the dishes and the food to the dining room: